☰

Home/Read / Source writing

← Search the writings

Tuesdays With Tony, Volume 5

The Courtroom in Our Hearts: A Sovereignty Series Finale, Part 1

By Tony Eldridge

From Tony’s manuscript. Original wording preserved.

View book and free download →
← Browse writingsAbout 7 min · Book section

There are moments when we realize how worn down we are.

Not just from what happened. Not just from waiting, grieving, praying, wondering, or trying to hold ourselves together while life unfolds in ways we would not have chosen. There is another kind of weariness beneath all of that. The weariness that comes from trying to make everything make sense before we are willing to rest.

We may not recognize it at first. We may think we are only asking questions, and sometimes we are. We may think we are only trying to understand, and there is nothing wrong with bringing our confusion before God. Scripture gives us room to cry out, to lament, to ask, to seek, to knock. But somewhere along the way, if we are not careful, the question can begin to change. It stops being, “Lord, help me understand,” and slowly becomes, “Lord, explain Yourself.”

And when that happens, something begins to shift inside us.

We are no longer only hurting. We are no longer only confused. We have begun carrying a courtroom in our hearts. God is summoned there again and again. His actions are questioned. His inactions are questioned. His timing is questioned. His silence is questioned. And without saying it that way, we begin waiting for Him to give an account before we fully trust Him again.

That kind of posture wears us down. And maybe that is part of what this whole journey has been exposing in us.

We have wrestled with the quiet belief that control was somehow shared. We have faced the disappointment of following Jesus and finding that the path did not look like what we thought we signed up for. We have felt the sting of what did not seem fair. We have strained beneath the ache of not understanding. We have resisted the truth that we are clay in the Potter’s hand. We have struggled with a God who warns and relents, judges and shows mercy. We have prayed to a God who could act, who had every right and power to act, and sometimes did not act in the way we hoped.

And through all of it, perhaps the deeper question was never only, “What is God doing?”

Perhaps the deeper question was, “Will we trust Him as God when we do not get to stand over what He is doing?”

Scripture speaks directly into this place, not by giving us control, and not by promising that every answer will be handed to us in this life, but by calling us back to the only posture that can hold us when understanding cannot.

“Trust in the LORD with all your heart, and do not lean on your own understanding.” (Proverbs 3:5 ESV).

That verse is easy to quote when life is steady. It becomes something else when our understanding is the very thing we are leaning on to survive. Because when life does not make sense, our instinct is to press harder into our understanding, not less. We replay. We examine. We search for the missing piece. We try to trace the line between what God allowed and what God intended, between what we prayed and what unfolded, between what we believe about His goodness and what we are experiencing in front of us.

And sometimes we tell ourselves that once we understand, then we will trust. Once we see the reason, then we will rest. Once the pieces come together, then we will let go. But trust that waits for understanding is still leaning on understanding. It may be patient. It may be sincere. It may even sound spiritual. But it is not yet the rest God is inviting us into. It is still asking explanation to do what only God Himself can do.

That is why the next line matters.

“In all your ways acknowledge him, and he will make straight your paths.” (Proverbs 3:6 ESV).

Not understand Him in all your ways. Not explain Him in all your ways. Not approve what He is doing in all your ways. Acknowledge Him. Recognize Him. See Him rightly. Bring every road, every fear, every disappointment, every unanswered question, and every ache that refuses to settle under the reality of who He is.

Job had to learn this in the ashes.

That is what makes his story so fitting for this moment in our journey. Job did not suffer because he had abandoned God. Scripture introduces him as blameless and upright, a man who feared God and turned away from evil. When everything was stripped from him, he did not immediately curse God. He worshiped.

“Then Job arose and tore his robe and shaved his head and fell on the ground and worshiped.” (Job 1:20 ESV).

And then he said words that still humble us.

“Naked I came from my mother’s womb, and naked shall I return. The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away; blessed be the name of the LORD.” (Job 1:21 ESV).

There is deep sovereignty in that response. Job knew God had the right to give. Job knew God had the right to take away. Job knew that blessing did not place God in our debt, and loss did not remove God from the throne.

And yet, as the suffering continued, as the silence stretched, as his friends accused him, as his body ached and his grief sat heavy on him, the desire for an answer grew. We understand that. We should be careful before we judge him too quickly, because pain has a way of pressing questions out of us we did not know were there.

At first, Job wanted to appeal. He wanted to understand. He wanted to bring his case before God. But over time, that desire for understanding became something stronger.

“Oh, that I had one to hear me! (Here is my signature! Let the Almighty answer me!) Oh, that I had the indictment written by my adversary!” (Job 31:35 ESV).

Let the Almighty answer me.

That is the line where the ache of suffering begins to reach toward the position of judgment. Job is not merely asking anymore. He is calling God to respond. He wants the indictment. He wants the explanation. He wants the hearing. He wants the Almighty to answer.

And if we are honest, we know something of that impulse.

Maybe we have not said it with Job’s words, but we have felt it when the prayer was not answered the way we begged for it to be answered, when something happened that seemed needless, cruel, unfair, or impossible to reconcile, when God was silent and the silence felt heavier than the pain itself. We have felt the quiet rise of that inner demand: Lord, how can this be right? How can this be good? How can You allow this and not tell me why?

That is the courtroom in our hearts.

It is the place where our pain begins presenting evidence against God. It is the place where our disappointment begins cross-examining His goodness. It is the place where His silence is treated as negligence, His timing as failure, and His refusal to act the way we hoped as something He must defend.

And that courtroom can feel righteous to us because the wound is real. The grief is real. The confusion is real. The question is real.

But the courtroom is still the wrong place for us to stand.

Because putting God on trial does not change His sovereignty. It only exhausts our souls under it. It does not make us safer. It does not make us wiser. It does not give us control. It only keeps us living in resistance to the One who cannot be overruled, cannot be corrected, cannot be judged by us, and cannot be made to answer as though He stands beneath our understanding.

Fighting God does not make Him less sovereign. It only makes us less at rest.

And maybe that is where we need to pause today.

Not with everything resolved. Not with every question settled. Not by pretending that the wound does not hurt or that the silence has been easy. But by becoming willing to see what has been happening inside us. Willing to recognize where our questions have started turning into accusations. Willing to notice where our desire for understanding has quietly become a demand for God to explain Himself.

Because the first step toward letting go is often seeing what we are still holding.

As we sit with this today, we take a moment to reflect on where we may still be carrying a courtroom in our hearts. Where have we been waiting for God to make His sovereignty make sense before we rest in Him? Where have we treated His actions or inactions as something He must explain before we trust Him again? And where might He be inviting us to stop standing over Him, and begin remembering our place before Him?

If you are willing, share your reflections or questions in the comments so we can learn and walk this journey together.


Continue your study

Read the full book free, or explore another question.

Search the writings →